Banner
Another Potent Reply PDF Print E-mail
Atheism and Apologetics - Letter to Mr. Harris
Written by Douglas Wilson   
Wednesday, 09 May 2007 01:48

If you are on an atheist jag as I am (and why shouldn't you be?), you really ought to get The Return of the Village Atheist. American Vision published it at the same time they published my Letter from a Christian Citizen. I got my copy the other day, and just finished it last night. It is also a response to Sam Harris' book, and while there are just a few areas where our responses overlap, for the most part Joel McDurmon addresses different problems with Harris, or the same problems in a different but equally effective way. This book is another potent answer to Harris.

One example. McDurmon points out that Harris doesn't understand the arguments of Intelligent Design, just as I did, but he goes on to juxtapose Harris' apparent ignorance of the irreducible complexity argument with Darwin's clear anticipation of that argument. "Since Darwin himself anticipated the ID argument as a full refutation of his theory," then it is not possible for Harris to say it is mere "religious advocacy masquerading as science," unless of course Harris believes that Darwin thought his theory was so rickety that it could be overthrown by something as flimsy as religious opinions (p. 65).

There are some other devastating arguments here as well. If this subject interests you at all, this book will interest you a great deal.



Add this page to your favorite Social Networking websites
Digg! Reddit! Del.icio.us! Mixx! Google! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! MySpace! Yahoo! BlogRolling! Twitter! LinkedIn! TwitThis
Last Updated on Wednesday, 09 May 2007 01:48
 
Comments
Search
Only registered users can write comments!
Joel McDurmon  Wednesday, May 09, 2007 3:01 am
Rev. Wilson,

Thank you for your kind words about my book. Knowing how madly busy you must be, it is a real privilege to have your review.

Nice work with Hitchins.

God bless,
Joel McDurmon
Grant L Hubbard  - Take yourself a little less seriously, and practic  Saturday, October 23, 2010 4:38 pm
In LETTER FROM A CHRISTIAN CITIZEN you base much of your introduction on the primise that atheism, which you equate with Darwinism, would inevitably produce monsters, see, e.g. p xv, 1st full paragraph, but that Christianity saves even the atheist from being a monster.
As a Christian I applaud sound defense of Christianity, but a little honesty would go far. Roughly half the world population are non-christian and non-Muslim and live lives of honesty and morality not unlike Christians. Even animals, with few exceptions, nuture their young and cooperate and defend their own.
I fear you like hearing and reading your words so much that you have exalted quantity far ahead of quantity.